Recently at Totally Driven we had a customer come in for an iron fitting. He had a full set of Mizuno MP 52 iron heads that he wanted us to shaft up for him. After going through the full fitting and determining the correct shaft, length, flex, grip, swing-weight, etc. he brought in the clubheads. They came in a box all neatly wrapped in plastic- brand new. As we are unable to purchase club-heads only from Mizuno, we asked him where he was able to get the clubheads. He said he had a friend that knew someone “on the inside” in Japan who was able to get these heads at a great price and that they were indeed real.
After our club-builder Jon Weedman put together the clubs including SST PURING the shafts we called the customer to set up an appointment to have us loft and lie the clubs. We always loft/lie after the clubs are built and test multiple clubs on a lie board to make sure the set is done perfectly. The process was going along fine other than the irons were more irregular than normal as far as loft/lie. After bending the first two irons with no problem, I had something very unusual happen. The third iron snapped apart in the loft/lie machine. Now, I am very experienced at loft/lie of irons. Not to say I have never broken one before but it is extremely rare. But these were supposed to be forged Mizunos that should bend easily and smoothly. Of course, I felt terrible and offered to replace this for the customer with a new one. Of course, now I had to finish the rest of the clubs, so I carefully started the next one. To my surprise, even though I was very careful, the next club snapped also.
Now our builder Jon and I remembered where the clubs had come from and were more than suspicious (as well as feeling awful). As Jon looked at the clubs closer it was very apparent the workmanship was poor on the heads. The bore on the heads was irregular, leaving a very thin side and a thick side. Of course the clubs had both broken along the thinner wall.
![Counterfeit clubs[1]](http://totallydrivengolf.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/counterfeit-clubs1.jpg?w=300&h=225)
Check out the thin wall on the right side of each club
Jon remembered that a friend of this customer had also brought in a set of Mizunos to loft and lie. Jon remembered they did not bend like a normal forged club either. We pulled out the loft/lie sheets we keep and found that the factory loft/lies were very irregular on that set also. Next, we pulled out the loft/lie sheets for a set of Mizuno Irons we had recently ordered directly from Mizuno and altered for a
University of Minnesota player. The loft/lie angles matched very closely with the Mizuno specs for the clubs although we had to alter them for the player.
Loft Lie comparisons below:
Purchased from Mizuno Customer A Customer B
3 iron -21/60 21/60.5 21/61
4 iron - 24/60 24/62.5 24/59.5
5 iron – 27/61 29/62.5 28/60.5
6 iron – 31/61.5 31/63 30.5/61.5
7 iron – 35/62 36/63.5 35/61
8 iron – 39/63 42/61.5 40/61
9 iron – 43/63 44/62.5 43.5/63.5
PW - 47/63.5 48/65 48/65
For those of you who aren’t familiar with loft and lie specs, the column on the left (purchased directly from Mizuno by Totally Driven) were quite close to factory specs – not perfect, but close.
The irons from customer A (two broken clubs) and customer B (his friend) were both very irregular with lies angles not graduating upwards consistently and lofts up to 3 degrees out of kilter. Needless to say it was very apparent to us (and the customer) that both of these sets were not Mizuno irons after all. They were almost definitely counterfeits. On closer inspection, even the paint fill color was not quite the same as a true Mizuno iron.

Hosel lengths different-no serial #
After looking closer we also saw that the hosel lengths were not the same and that the real Mizuno iron has a serial number on the rear of the hosel and the other does not.
Now, I’m not writing this to embarrass these customers. In fact, we feel bad for them. These are not the only counterfeits we have seen or suspected. It is becoming more common. Player A not only decided to replace the two broken irons, but to have us order a whole set from Mizuno. He could not live with knowing that 6 other irons were not really Mizuno’s ( and probably not even forged irons based on how they broke). The overall expense was considerable, but he said it was a good lesson learned.
So, for those of you who like to buy clubs from EBay or other online sources, beware. If the price is too good to be true, the clubs are probably not “real”. Even if the price is about what you would expect, I would just caution- buyer beware!
Andy Thompson
www.totallydriven.com